Heritage and the Home Renovation Tax Credit

As part of the economic stimulus package, the Government of Canada is offering Canadians tax credits for renovations undertaken between January 27, 2009 and February 1, 2010.     The guidelines emphasize that to be eligible, alterations “must be of an enduring nature and integral to the dwelling.”   Given the speed at which the legislation was drafted, it comes as no surprize that there is no recognition of the vulnerability of our built heritage to short deadlines and sales pressure.

Particularly at risk are original windows.  The bill favours broad-based contractors who sell mass-produced elements. These contractors can be in and out in a day.    Carpenters who  replicate elements using historical techniques will be at a disadvantage when bidding against firms that can guarantee homeowners a twenty-four hour turn-about.    Moreover,  restoration of heritage elements cannot usually be done in winter.  Replacement with vinyl or aluminum windows is now offered after the snow flies.

Heritage Committees (Local Architecture Advisory Committees) can expect to experience pressure from owners of heritage properties who are in a hurry to meet the deadline and get the tax credit.  In most Canadian jurisdictions, owners of such properties need municipal approval of alterations before they  can engage a contractor.  Typically, Heritage Committees only meet once a month and may take several months to sort out the options and make a decision.  Rural Committees are at a particular disadvantage in responding to requests as experts and resources are not usually close at hand.

Also disadvantaged will be the tiny cohort of stonemasons, woodcarvers, glaziers who work on heritage projects.  These skilled, niche trades have been encouraged by governments in recent years through job training initiatives and the like.  It is very doubtful that there are enough workers  to complete the summer’s avalanche of  jobs.  To make the deadline,  contracts  will be given to non-specialists which under other circumstances would be held until a specialist tradesman were available.

The heritage community like the rest of Canada was taken by surprize by the Home Renovation Tax Credit.  It is unfortunate, as an opportunity has been missed to offer owners of important properties an advantage.  The legislation could have been written to give owners of designated, heritage properties a longer time frame to complete alterations and still qualify for credit.  This would have enabled Heritage Committees and historical restoration specialists to encourage consideration of preservation through appropriate repair, or at least by historical replication.    A time extension would have recognized and rewarded the important role of property owners in looking after our built heritage, and would have cost Canada next to nothing.

Advertisements

2 Comments

Filed under Architecture, History, Ontario, Material culture, Uncategorized

2 responses to “Heritage and the Home Renovation Tax Credit

  1. JoAnne Himmelman

    Jennifer, a very compelling thought regarding “What’s A Historical Society to Do?”, having lived and breathed this situation for a long time, I don’t even want to think about what is coming to us poor museums. I can’t imagine trying to operate a museum on even less funding that what is presently available. But do we “choose” our battles and continue to plug away with our meager funds and chance losing what is around us until the “big” fight is needed. I don’t know. Sometimes seems all so in vane. One needs to stay optimistic that our vision and work will prevail and what is “Canadian” will be preserved for the future, despite having no money or sometimes public understanding of what our “fight” is.

  2. although I misuse a lot of of my night on the net playing video games like facebook poker or petville, I nonetheless like to utilize some time to read a couple of information sites sometimes and I am proud to report this latest posting is in reality quite good and drastically more beneficial than half the various poor quality junk I read today , anyways i’m off to enjoy a few rounds of zynga poker

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s